| Year | All-Stars | ||
 |
|||
| 2012 | Prince Fielder*, Miguel Cabrera, Justin Verlander* | ||
|
|||
| 2011 | Miguel Cabrera, Jose Valverde, Alex Avila*, Justin Verlander*, Jhonny Peralta | ||
|
|||
| 2010 | Miguel Cabrera*, Jose Valverde | ||
|
|||
|
|||
| 2009 | Brandon Inge, Justin Verlander, Curtis Granderson, Edwin Jackson | ||
|
|||
| 2008 | Carlos Guillen | ||
|
|||
| 2007 | Ivan Rodriguez*, Magglio Ordonez*, Placido Polanco, Carlos Guillen, Justin Verlander | ||
|
|||
| 2006 | Ivan Rodriguez, Magglio Ordonez, Kenny Rogers | ||
|
|||
| 2005 | Ivan Rodriguez | ||
|
|||
| 2004 | Carlos Guillen, Ivan Rodriguez* | ||
|
|||
| 2003 | Dmitri Young | ||
|
|||
| 2002 | Robert Fick | ||
|
|||
| 2001 | Tony Clark | ||
|
|||
| 2000 | Todd Jones | ||
|
|||
| 1999 | Brad Ausmus | ||
|
|||
| 1998 | Damion Easley | ||
|
|||
| 1997 | Justin Thompson | ||
|
|||
| 1996 | Travis Fryman | ||
|
|||
| 1995 | David Wells | ||
|
|||
| 1994 | Travis Fryman, Mickey Tettleton | ||
|
|||
| 1993 | Cecil Fielder, Travis Fryman | ||
|
|||
| 1992 | Travis Fryman | ||
|
|||
| 1991 | Cecil Fielder* | ||
|
|||
| 1990 | Cecil Fielder, Alan Trammell | ||
|
|||
| 1989 | Mike Henneman | ||
|
|||
| 1988 | Doyle Alexander, Alan Trammell* | ||
|
|||
| 1987 | Jack Morris, Matt Nokes, Alan Trammell, Lou Whitaker | ||
|
|||
| 1986 | Willie Hernandez, Lance Parrish*, Lou Whitaker* | ||
|
|||
| 1985 | Willie Hernandez, Jack Morris*, Lance Parrish*, Dan Petry, Alan Trammell, Lou Whitaker* | ||
|
|||
| 1984 | Willie Hernandez, Chet Lemon*, Jack Morris, Lance Parrish*, Alan Trammell, Lou Whitaker* | ||
|
|||
| 1983 | Aurelio Lopez, Lance Parrish, Lou Whitaker | ||
|
|||
| 1982 | Lance Parrish | ||
|
|||
| 1981 | Jack Morris* | ||
|
|||
| 1980 | Lance Parrish, Alan Trammell | ||
|
|||
| 1979 | Steve Kemp | ||
|
|||
| 1978 | Jason Thompson | ||
|
|||
| 1977 | Mark Fidrych, Jason Thompson | ||
|
|||
| 1976 | Mark Fidrych*, Ron LeFlore*, Rusty Staub* | ||
|
|||
| 1975 | Bill Freehan | ||
|
|||
| 1974 | John Hiller, Al Kaline | ||
|
|||
| 1973 | Ed Brinkman, Bill Freehan, Willie Horton | ||
|
|||
| 1972 | Norm Cash, Bill Freehan*, Mickey Lolich | ||
|
|||
| 1971 | Norm Cash*, Bill Freehan*, Al Kaline, Mickey Lolich | ||
|
|||
| 1970 | Bill Freehan*, Willie Horton | ||
|
|||
| 1969 | Bill Freehan*, Mickey Lolich, Denny McLain | ||
|
|||
| 1968 | Bill Freehan*, Willie Horton*, Denny McLain, Don Wert | ||
|
|||
| 1967 | Bill Freehan*, Al Kaline*, Dick McAuliffe | ||
|
|||
| 1966 | Norm Cash, Bill Freehan*, Al Kaline, Dick McAuliffe*, Denny McLain* | ||
|
|||
| 1965 | Bill Freehan*, Willie Horton*, Al Kaline, Dick McAuliffe* | ||
|
|||
| 1964 | Bill Freehan, Al Kaline, Jerry Lumpe | ||
|
|||
| 1963 | Jim Bunning, Al Kaline* | ||
|
|||
| 1962 (Game 2) | Hank Aguirre, Jim Bunning, Rocky Colavito, Al Kaline | ||
|
|||
| 1962 (Game 1) | Hank Aguirre, Jim Bunning, Rocky Colavito | ||
|
|||
| 1961 (Game 2) | Jim Bunning, Norm Cash*, Al Kaline | ||
|
|||
| 1961 (Game 1) | Jim Bunning, Norm Cash*, Al Kaline, Frank Lary | ||
|
|||
| 1960 (Game 2) | Al Kaline, Frank Lary | ||
|
|||
| 1960 (Game 1) | Al Kaline, Frank Lary | ||
|
|||
| 1959 (Game 2) | Al Kaline, Harvey Kuenn | ||
|
|||
| 1959 (Game 1) | Jim Bunning, Al Kaline, Harvey Kuenn | ||
|
|||
| 1958 | Al Kaline, Harvey Kuenn | ||
|
|||
| 1957 | Jim Bunning*, Al Kaline*, Harvey Kuenn*, Charlie Maxwell | ||
|
|||
| 1956 | Ray Boone, Al Kaline*, Harvey Kuenn*, Charlie Maxwell | ||
|
|||
| 1955 | Billy Hoeft, Al Kaline*, Harvey Kuenn* | ||
|
|||
| 1954 | Ray Boone*, Harvey Kuenn | ||
|
|||
| 1953 | Harvey Kuenn | ||
|
|||
| 1952 | Vic Wertz | ||
|
|||
| 1951 | Fred Hutchinson, George Kell*, Vic Wertz | ||
|
|||
| 1950 | Hoot Evers*, Ted Gray, Art Houtteman, George Kell* | ||
|
|||
| 1949 | George Kell*, Virgil Trucks, Vic Wertz | ||
|
|||
| 1948 | Hoot Evers*, George Kell, Pat Mullin*, Hal Newhouser | ||
|
|||
| 1947 | George Kell*, Pat Mullin, Hal Newhouser*, Dizzy Trout | ||
|
|||
| 1946 | Hal Newhouser | ||
|
|||
| 1945 | Hank Greenberg (See note at bottom) | ||
|
|||
| 1944 | Pinky Higgins, Hal Newhouser, Dizzy Trout, Rudy York | ||
|
|||
| 1943 | Hal Newhouser, Dick Wakefield*, Rudy York | ||
|
|||
| 1942 | Al Benton, Hal Newhouser, Birdie Tebbetts*, Rudy York* | ||
|
|||
| 1941 | Al Benton, Birdie Tebbetts, Rudy York* | ||
|
|||
| 1940 | Tommy Bridges, Hank Greenberg*, Bobo Newsom | ||
|
|||
| 1939 | Tommy Bridges, Hank Greenberg*, Bobo Newsom | ||
|
|||
| 1938 | Charlie Gehringer*, Hank Greenberg, Vern Kennedy, Rudy York | ||
|
|||
| 1937 | Tommy Bridges, Charlie Gehringer*, Hank Greenberg, Gee Walker | ||
|
|||
| 1936 | Tommy Bridges, Charlie Gehringer*, Goose Goslin, Schoolboy Rowe | ||
|
|||
| 1935 | Tommy Bridges, Mickey Cochrane, Charlie Gehringer*, Schoolboy Rowe | ||
|
|||
| 1934 | Tommy Bridges, Mickey Cochrane, Charlie Gehringer* | ||
|
|||
| 1933 | Charlie Gehringer* | ||
|
|||
| Note: No game was played in 1945, although teams were selected * Voted to start or started Selected but replaced due to injury Selected but did not appear in game |
|||
